The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council has upheld the validity of the 2011 State of Public Emergency and the Emergency Regulations used to arrest and detain three men.
In its judgment delivered on November 17th, 2026, the panel of judges dismissed the appeals brought by Dominic Pitilal, Earl Elie and Ashmeed Mohammed challenging the proclamation and regulations, finding that the Constitutional test for declaring a public emergency had been satisfied.
The emergency was declared on August 21st, 2011, by then President George Maxwell Richards, acting on Cabinet’s advice, during the administration of Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar.
It came amid a surge in murders and gang-related violence, with 11 murders recorded over three days between August 19th and 21st, bringing the murder toll for the year to 260.
The circumstances outlined at the time also included intelligence warnings of possible gang reprisals following major police operations against drug trafficking, including a seizure valued at more than $20 million.
The Privy Council found that the evidence established a public emergency in which criminal activity and violence on a sufficiently extensive scale endangered the lives and safety of citizens.
“That under the Constitution, a public emergency exists when there is a situation where the lives or safety of citizens, not just a few but more generally, are endangered. The Board agrees that this can occur in a number of ways including where there is criminal activity of such a nature and on so extensive a scale that it endangers the lives of the citizens or threatens the ability of a government to provide for the safety of its citizens.”
It also upheld the finding that the Emergency Regulations were reasonably justifiable for dealing with the situation.
“The Board upholds the decision of the Court of Appeal that the proclamation was justified on the facts and is Constitutional and valid. The Board also finds that the regulations were reasonably justifiable. The measures introduced were clearly needed to address the sudden and extreme outbreak of widespread brutal violence.”
However, the Board allowed part of the appeals brought by Dominic Pitilal and Sergeant Earl Elie.
It reinstated compensation awards of $50,000 each after finding that their Constitutional right to consult an attorney had been breached.
The judgment makes clear that the seriousness of allegations, or the confidentiality of an investigation, does not justify denying a detained person access to legal advice.
“There was no justification for the police to have denied them their right to consult with a legal advisor. In this regard, the Court of Appeal was wrong to say that an individual must show that he has suffered some detriment by being deprived of legal advice before he can obtain compensation.”
The appeals also involved challenges to the arrests and detention of the three men. The Privy Council’s decision on the validity of the emergency and its regulations was separate from the individual findings concerning their treatment.
All three men were released without charge when the State of Emergency ended on December 5th, 2011.