Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar SC has welcomed today’s landmark judgment by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council dismissing the appeals challenging the constitutionality of her decision to declare a State of Emergency in August 2011 and the validity of the Emergency Powers Regulations.
In a post on social media, she said the historic judgment vindicates her decision to take firm action to protect the lives of innocent, law-abiding citizens from escalating gang violence, brutal murders and widespread lawlessness.
She said she rightly stood firm against violent criminals in 2011, and will continue to use the full authority of the law to protect citizens from violent criminal gangs.
“I acted then, as I will always act, in the best interests of the law-abiding people of Trinidad and Tobago. The Privy Council recognised that the evidence demonstrated ‘a threat to the life of the nation in a very literal way” and found ample evidence justifying the declaration of the State of Emergency and the emergency measures implemented.”
Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar also noted that the Privy Council recognised that its judgment carries important implications for the more recent States of Emergency declared in July 2025 and March 2026, where similar circumstances existed and materially similar Emergency Powers Regulations were enacted.
“This judgement reaffirms that determining whether a public emergency exists is primarily the responsibility of the Executive, subject to Parliamentary approval and Constitutional scrutiny. It also recognises that governments must sometimes act upon sensitive national security intelligence that cannot be publicly disclosed without compromising operations and endangering lives. The judgement reinforces the constitutional principles we have articulated in Parliament concerning the Government’s authority to implement strong and lawful measures to restore peace and security. The Privy Council itself emphasised that “It is the first responsibility of government in a democratic society to protect and safeguard the lives of its citizens.” That is a responsibility I take extremely seriously.”
The Prime Minister emphatically stated that she will never accept a situation where violent criminals enjoy greater freedom than innocent, law-abiding citizens.
“No mother should have to fear for her children’s lives, no family should be held hostage by gangs, and no community should be surrendered to criminals. Those who demand decisive action against crime cannot simultaneously condemn every constitutional measure designed to protect our citizens. Political disagreement does not automatically make a national security decision unconstitutional.”
Mrs Persad-Bissessar predicted that the PNM challenge to the Special Operations legislation will also fail in the courts.
“My government will fight them brutally and viciously every day until they cease inflicting their evil on our nation. If they continue to inflict terror on law-abiding citizens, I will reciprocate that terror on them and their families; that is a guarantee.”
The Prime Minister said she remains firmly committed to supporting national security agencies, strengthening the laws and taking the necessary action to restore safety and security throughout Trinidad and Tobago.