Political Scientist: Privy Council Ruling On SOE Comes At Critical Time For PM

The Privy Council’s ruling upholding the 2011 State of Emergency has renewed focus on the use of emergency powers in Trinidad and Tobago.

Political Scientist Professor Hamid Ghany says the Privy Council’s endorsement of the 2011 SOE comes at a critical moment for Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar, who is back at the helm and confronting a crime wave that is far worse than the one she faced in 2011.

“So the significance lies in the fact, one, there is vindication from 2011, and two, she is in power to be able to receive the benefit of that opinion at a time when her government is involved in fighting serious crime. The situation obviously got worse over that period of 15 years. She’s come back to power now and is dealing with a problem that has been magnified several times over from what it was before.”

The Professor said the judgment shows the 2011 SOE was not a political decision but one based on intelligence — presented to the National Security Council, considered by then Minister of National Security Brigadier John Sandy, and declared by the President.

“There’s been a fair amount of public commentary that has gone on over the years, very loose and irresponsible public commentary suggesting that these decisions are made willy-nilly and that someone just decides to wake up one morning and decide, you know what, we’re going to have a State of Emergency today. It does not work like that.”

He noted the ruling has implications for the more recent States of Emergency in December 2024, July 2025 and March 2026 — all built on a regulatory template dating back to 1970 and 1990. He dismissed the idea of the SOE as a crime plan.

“Although there have been calls and some comments that have been made that suggested that State of Emergency is a crime plan, and what have you, State of Emergency is not a crime plan. State of Emergency is designed for extreme situations, and the government has used State of Emergency for extreme situations.”

Professor Ghany says the intelligence available to police and national security authorities shows crime has deteriorated significantly since 2011 — including, he noted, alleged threats to assassinate public officials, which sound, in his words, eerily familiar to more recent times. He believes the judgment will help bring that reality out into the open, so citizens can finally see the full picture.

Translate »