I welcome the landmark judgment of the Privy Council in the appeals brought by Dominic Pitilal, Earl Elie and Ashmeed Mohammed. It represents a historic vindication of Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar’s leadership and the Government’s decision to declare the 2011 state of emergency to protect the people of Trinidad and Tobago.
It also vindicates the innovative and solid legal leadership currently provided by Attorney General John Jeremie SC at a time when the State must invoke the full powers under the Constitution to bring the country back from the precipice of lawless descent. This is a remarkable victory for the State, for which Mr Jeremie must be given full credit. His vast legal knowledge, experience and expertise have guided the State to a successful outcome on questions of profound national importance. He has navigated this legal ship to a safe legal port and put the lie to claims that the declaration of the 2011 emergency was unconstitutional and would expose the State to claims for millions of dollars.
This landmark judgment supports the legal stance taken by Attorney General Jeremie in bringing strong laws to protect and defend law-abiding citizens who are at the mercy of violent criminals. The Privy Council’s reasoning supports the constitutional principles articulated by the PM and the AG in Parliament and demonstrates the depth of their knowledge of constitutional law. It shows that Mr Jeremie is correct in stating that the Government can take drastic measures to restore law and order where the constitutional requirements are satisfied.
As AG when the challenged state of emergency was declared, I recall the relentless political attacks upon PM Persad-Bissessar and our administration. We were confronted with brutal killings, escalating gang violence and intelligence pointing to an immediate threat to public safety. We chose to act. Today, our country’s highest court has upheld the constitutional foundation of that action.
The Privy Council rejected the challenges to both the declaration of the emergency and the validity of the emergency regulations under which the appellants were arrested and detained. On those central constitutional questions, the Government’s position has been vindicated. The Law Lords found that “There was ample evidence … of the initial state of emergency created by the sudden and extreme outbreak of widespread, brutal violence in August 2011. They also found that the measures were justified and stated that “the measures in issue were clearly the sorts of measures which are needed to deal with that kind of emergency.”
These findings answer those who sought to portray the Government’s response as constitutionally unjustified. The emergency was real. The danger was serious. The Constitution permitted decisive action.
The judgment supports PM Persad-Bissessar’s hardline approach to the fight against crime. She understands that the Government must use the full weight and authority of the law when bandits are enjoying more freedom than innocent, law-abiding citizens. The Privy Council appreciated this and said “It is the first responsibility of government in a democratic society to protect and safeguard the lives of its citizens.” — paragraph 91.
The Board also recognised that security decisions require the assessment of intelligence which cannot always be disclosed publicly. It asked the courts to trust the national security agencies to do their job, stating that this responsibility “lies with the Government and the law enforcement agencies rather than with the courts.”
The responsibility for assessing threats and responding to them rests primarily with the elected Government, subject to parliamentary supervision and constitutional scrutiny by the courts. Political opponents cannot turn their disagreement with a security measure into proof that it is unconstitutional.
The judgment is particularly relevant to the Government’s continuing determination to confront gangs, violent criminals and the trafficking of drugs and guns. The Government is developing and implementing innovative legal measures to restore safety to communities where ordinary families live under the shadow of criminal violence.
It is high time that we unite in the fight against crime to save our beloved country. Far too many put political advantage ahead of constructive cooperation in the fight against crime. They cannot demand decisive action against gangs and then reflexively condemn the legal tools intended to confront them. The public deserves serious alternatives and informed constitutional debate.
I congratulate Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar and Attorney General John Jeremie on this historic constitutional victory. Their leadership deserves support as they continue the difficult work of reclaiming our communities from violent criminals and protecting the people of Trinidad and Tobago.
Anand Ramlogan SC
Former Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago